Site Meter Nutrition Frenzy » Blog Archive » WestSoy v. 8th Continent: A Soymilk Smackdown

WestSoy v. 8th Continent: A Soymilk Smackdown

by Amanda Herrington

Healthy

Recently on Oprah, self-proclaimed health guru Bob Green put his “Best Life Diet” stamp of approval on 8th Continent Brand soymilk.

Personally, I get the feeling ol’ Bob is just out to make a buck by endorsing products that may taste o.k., but are not the best option for the health conscious consumer. I also think we should take a second look at anything, endorsed by anyone, who associates his image with McDonalds, home of the heart attack.

Instead of using 8th Continent for your smoothies or cereal, I recommend WestSoy Organic Soymilk.

WestSoy is Organic, whereas 8th Continent is labeled “premium”. Huh? Until there are FDA standards for what “premium” is, I’ll choose organic products.

Here are the ingredients in Westsoy Unsweetened Plain Soymilk: filtered water and organic soybeans. Period. This is aligned with a great rule of thumb - the shorter the ingredient list, the more nutritious and less processed the product.

Plain Westsoy has 90 calories per cup, 4,5 g fat, 5 g carbs and a big 4g of fiber. Fiber count is especially important since it effectively “cancels out” the 5g of carbs leaving you with a net 1g of impact carbs. It also boasts only 1 g sugar, and 9 g protein. For you sodium watchers -only 30g per delicious serving.

Chocoholic? Go for West Soy Unsweetened Chocolate, made with pure cocoa. At 100 calories per cup, 4.5 g fat , 6g carbohydrate and 5 g fiber (again, net carbs come in at 1 g!), it is an outstanding way to make luscious smoothies without added sugar.

For an even sweeter sensation, I recommend adding a packet of all-natural Stevia extract (I like Sunlabel by Complete Earth Products) to make the perfect sugar-free chocolate smoothie.

Now the info on 8th Continent Plain Soymilk: 80 calories per cup with 3g of fat. Now be careful - although the fat content is lower than WestSoy, a serving of 8th Continent has 8g carbohydrate, ZERO fiber (no “cancellation” of those carbs), and 7g of sugar.

People, anything with more than 4g of sugar (we’re talking sugar sugar here, not just fructose which is sugar from fruit) per serving is bad news.

The sodium content of 160g is more than double WestSoy as well.

8th Continent Chocolate Soymilk is even worse ; 90cal, 13g carbs, ( again, zero fiber), 11g sugar and 190g sodium. Besides these not –so- hot stats, the thing that really weirds me out about 8th Soy is that the second ingredient listed on its label, righ after “soymilk”, is sugar. Sugar is followed by fructose, modified corn starch , sucralose( care for a tumor anyone?) and a substantial string of preservatives.

Another dietary landmine endorsed by Bobby Green ( I am wondering just how much of cut must he gets from this crap?) is the “Limited Edition” 8th Continent Smoothie. The jingle on this one is, “lose the blender”. A more accurate description would be, “lose the blender, keep the weight”.

I mean, come on Bob, for those of us battling the bulge the Chocolate- Strawberry Banana smoothie is positively gruesome choice and you know it! It contains – 100 cals, 18 g carbs, no fiber, 12g of sugar and 180mg sodium. Blech.

Much more respectable is 8th Continent ‘s “light” version. This one is 50 calories, 10g fat, 2 carbs and only 1g sugar. However, sugar is still the second ingredient on its label, and it has zero fiber, is not organic and contain preservatives.

I do think 8th Continent has pretty packaging. So, if you are interested in eating the nifty label and drinking great marketing, this is the soy for you. Aside from that, I am baffled as to how it could be a “healthy life” selection when there are much better options.

But, as always, the choice is really yours. Just don’t come crying to me when your ass still looks big as Texas in your Daisy Dukes this spring.

You know I love you, so try this smoothie recipe for a delicious treat that will keep you satisfied and gorgeous:

–1 C WestSoy Unsweetened Organic Soy
–1 C cold water
–1 Scoop Chocolate Whey or Soy protein powder
–1 TBSPN cocoa powder
–1 TBSPN chunky peanut or almond butter
–1 small frozen banana (or 1 C frozen strawberries or frozen apple or pear chunks)
–1 TBSPN ground flax seeds
–1-2 Stevia packets
–3 ice cubes

Blend and love!

, , ,


Leave a Reply


About Nutrition Frenzy

Welcome to Nutrition Frenzy, where you’ll find information, news and updates about foods, nutrition and exercise and how they impact your life. There is a wealth of information in the world today, sometimes it can be overwhelming. This blog will bring you the information in a clear, logical and concise way for you to mentally ‘digest’ and take from it what you will. It is my hope that you will bring your experience, knowledge and expertise to the table as well. We can only learn if we continue to share information for everyone to learn.

Nutrition Frenzy Author(s)
    » Brick-ONeil

Science & Health Channel Posts

  • The Side Effects of Switching to Vegetarianism
    There's a common issue faced by nearly every new vegetarian. Worldwide, people changing their diet to a meat-free one are seeing the same thing happen. I experienced it a few years back when I [...]
  • Coffee House Inspires a New Kind of Smoothie
    There a little coffee house downtown where I live - Crossroads Cafe - that is vegan friendly. On their listing of soups, you'll find "Three Bean Vegan Chili." They have soy milk. One time, they even [...]
  • 6 guilt-free reasons to love carbs
    It’s time to give up the carb guilt. When we pack on the pounds, we often blame it on eating too many carbohydrates. But not all carbs are loaded with starchy calories. And if you severely limit [...]
  • Why So Many People Are Going Gluten-Free -- Should You?
    If you’ve ever polished off a fresh baguette or fought over that last slice of deep-dish pizza, you’ve eaten gluten. It’s the healthy plant protein found in several grains that, among other [...]
  • An Ocean of Acid?
    If you pay attention to the news, and especially news on the state of the environment, you may have heard of something called "ocean acidification." This is a very serious issue that is just [...]
  • Super Veges, to the rescue!
    Your mom said it. My mom said it. Every mom in the history of the world probably said it. Every night, at the dinner table. No, not "stop hitting your brother/sister" - but "Eat your vegetables, or [...]
  • Oops: Fur Company Uses Stella McCartney's Bra in Ad
    If you are Stella McCartney, and you are an animal rights activist who is outspoken about making only vegan clothes, where is the last place that you would expect to see your designs pop up? If [...]
  • True or False: Meat Eaters Have More Free Time than Vegetarians?
    False. Vegetarians are just more productive with their free time and thus never cause people to shake their heads and mutter "where does he get the time?..." That being said ... Someone [...]
  • Nutrition Frenzy has a new Blogger!
    Hello, my name is Brick ONeil, and I'm the new Nutrition Frenzy Blogger! I've been with 451 Press since March, 2007, blogging on Encouraging Health, and am enjoying my time here immensly. I'm [...]
  • A Super and Safe Appetite Suppressant?
    It burns fat, fends off disease, strengthens our bones, and improves our mood -- and now studies suggest it may even suppress our appetites. What's this miracle of modern medicine? Actually, it's [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Family Vacation Continued
    I wrote that last post for opinions just as it seemed.  Now, I'll tell you why I'm asking.  My husband and I have worked hard in the last year.  Owning a daycare is seriously one of [...]
  • Kerron Stewart Advances Through Two Rounds Of Women's 200 Meters At Olympic Games
    Former Auburn track and field star Kerron Stewart opened her quest for a second individual medal at the Olympic Games Tuesday, competing in the first two rounds of the women's 200 meters. Stewart, [...]
  • Microsoft's intention to buy DataAllegro, Inc.
    On July 24th, Microsoft announced that it intends to acquire DATAllegro Inc., a provider of breakthrough data warehouse appliances. The acquisition will extend the capabilities of Microsoft’s [...]
  • Let the game talk begin...
    In between Ollie and April's bitching about Jerry and Keesha and calling them names before moving on to the next target to do the same (...I quit listening...) there was some game talk between Renny [...]
  • Did Paris Hilton have a boob job?
    Hey guys! I know you missed me as I missed you. And no, I didn’t go for another ‘hibernation,’ my computer got corrupted from some virus I do not know (come on, I’m not really a [...]
  • This week of the scheduled View re-runs
    In case you are curious which re-runs are airing this week on The View, here is the list, along with links to the previous re-caps, where available: MON., AUG. 18 (OAD: 4/21/08) – Guest [...]
  • WWE Storyline - Rebecca's Injury
    HBK rendering aid to his wife after Y2J just punched her in the face.."accidently" at SummerSlam With the actions Jericho has taken to Shawn Michaels this passed week. Y2J inadvertently hit [...]
  • Paris Hilton’s mystery boobs get solved
    At least that is what Hollyscoop confirms. According to the website, “The mystery behind Paris Hilton's big boobs has been solved, and no, it doesn't involve plastic surgery.” That’s [...]
  • Force Unleashed Demo "Unleashes" This Week... HAR HAR
    If you can't wait for over the top, unbelievable and extreme to the max Star Wars action that's like, TOTALLY UNLEASHED, then you should be happy to know that Star Wars: Unleashed is having a [...]
  • Good morning, BBCrazies!
    The house guests are awake and sucking down coffee while mumbling small talk. Dan wants to have a pool party, and Michelle is suspicious since he just got out of the Diary Room - although I think [...]